Ask Todd Miller *Metal Roofing Expert

Going Over Old Roofs

Written by Todd Miller on December 15, 2009 | Filed under: Misc,Roofing Answers

I recently received an email asking:
“I hear differing opinions on installing metal over old shingles. Can the metal be too much weight on a home?”

My Answer:
Most metal roofs weigh from 40 pounds per square (aluminum) up to maybe 145 (for stone coated steel). A square is 100 square feet. Asphalt shingles on the other hand weigh from 275 – 450 pounds. When you get into products like slate and tile, weights can be pushing 2000 pounds per square!

These numbers show just how miniscule the weight of metal is.

Building codes allow two layers of standard shingles – that would be up to 900 pounds per square. Additionally, most homes are constructed to carry at least 3000 pounds of snowload for that area.

As asphalt (or fiberglass) shingles age, they lose weight. This is from granules that wear off and oils that evaporate. I have never seen any studies on this but it would not surprise me if an aged asphalt shingle has lost 30% of its original weight.

For that reason, in many cases, putting a metal roof over an aged shingle roof may still be less total weight than when the asphalt shingle was originally installed!

Now, while building codes say no more than two layers of roofing shingles, I have had many instances over the years when building inspectors have allowed metal as a third layer, because of the weight issues.

Tags: ,

3 responses to “Going Over Old Roofs”

  1. Nathan L. says:

    One advantage of removing the slate:

    You can often resell it for pretty good prices which helps pay for the cost of tearing it off.

  2. toddmiller says:


    That is a good question. First of all I would never suggest doing anything without the approval of your metal roofing manufacturer.

    That said, as a manufacturer of metal roofing, I have been involved with a few successful installations over slate. What I suggest is using a self drilling self tapping stainless steel screw for fastening. If test fasteners show that your slate is such that these fasteners can be used without cracking the slate badly then this sort of installation has potential. If not, then tear off and if necessary re-deck will be required.

  3. bruce poole says:

    can i have a metal roof installed on top of my slate roof?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Todd

Todd's expertise comes from his years of experience in metal roofing manufacturing. As president of Isaiah Industries, based in Piqua Ohio, Todd runs a several of the world’s leading manufacturers of residential metal roofing; Classic Metal Roofing Systems, Kassel & Irons, and Green American Home. His personal goal is to educate homeowners of the long-life benefits of metal roofing.

Sometimes finding the right roofing product is the easy part.

Need help finding a local, quality metal roofing contractor or supplier? I can help.

Find a Contractor or Supplier

Thinking about a new roof?

Educate yourself for a better experience when buying a new roof

This comprehensive eBook includes everything you'll need from "choosing a manufacturer" to a "metal roofing checklist," and is sure to be a great tool for helping you make the best investment in you home’s protection.

Get your copy!
classic metal roofing systems logo kassel and irons logo kassel and irons logo