Battens or no Battens?

November 7, 2011 | Filed under: Battens or No Battens, Misc, Roofing Answers, Roofing Installation

Greg from Florida recently sent me this question:

Q: I am looking to have a metal roof installed over my existing single layer shingle roof. I have had several estimates from companies but the one difference I see is that some companies want to use purlins (battens) and others do not. Are there a advantages / disadvantages to using purlins in this situation?

Here is my reply:

A: Good question. The first part of my response has to do with the suitability of the product for this application. There are a very few metal roof styles which MUST be installed over battens. There are some which can be installed over battens or solid decking and of course there are others which must be installed over solid decking.

Assuming the roofing you’re having installed can be installed over battens or solid decking, you then have the question of which to do. Frankly, folks will probably tell you that condensation control is a reason for using them. There really is very little validity to that in my 30+ years of experience. If the home has a well vented attic space, there is no reason for the metal roof to be mounted on battens.

The benefit to putting it on battens, though, is that the thermal break caused by the airspace will help some with energy efficiency. However, if your attic is vented well and you’re using a roof panel with reflective pigment, the added benefit of the cavity f is minimal.

The issues with battens are they can make the roof less walkable and they also mean you have to have extra trims to cover up the depth. This could also mean you will have to raise the gutters on the home if there are any.

I hope this helps. Please contact me whenever I might be of service.

4 responses to “Battens or no Battens?”

  1. bob says:

    Will metal roofing leak if screwed on top of roof shingles with no pearlings ?

  2. Del says:

    I told my roofer I wanted 24 gage metal
    in a beautiful copper color.
    Very reflective and 12” wide panels.
    He told me he ordered it in 16” panels
    instead. He said it was better then 12” wife. Is that true.
    I live close to Houston Texas, we get a lot of rain, and severe heat.

    • toddmiller says:

      Proper installation will trump everything else. Wider panels are less expensive than more narrow panels and they also install faster. Both can work well though there is a greater chance of oil canning usually the wider the panel is. Sometimes striations are added to the panels to try to combat that. A lot of times when considering panel width, I will think about the size of the home. Larger homes can handle the look of wider panels. Smaller homes usually look better to scale with a narrow panel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Do You Have a Metal Roof?
Tell Us About Your Experience.

I hear from a many homeowners about their metal roofing experiences, some good, some bad, and everything in between. Will you help others do their roofing research by adding a review of your metal roofing experience? It takes less than 5 minutes, and your investment of that time is greatly appreciated. .

Leave A Review